Claris Law Legal Blogging Community

Name:

E-mail:

Phone Number:

Zip Code:

Your Question:

Editor: Will Hanlon & Charlie Lambert
Profession: Tampa Defense Attorneys

Category: DUI

State v. W; Judge: Lawrence Lefler; Date: June 1, 2007

FACTS: The client was pulled over because his radio was too loud. The officer claimed he could hear the radio 75 feet away. In the state of Florida, if your radio is audible within 25 feet, an officer can stop your vehicle, and give you a citation. Whenever someone is pulled over, they typically become nervous, even if it's just a speeding ticket. In this case, however, the defendant had a panic disorder, which made him appear extremely nervous on the video. His voice wasn't slurred and he never swayed while he spoke to the officer, but he also never stopped talking. He continued to tell the officer that he was too nervous to take the test. Once the officer realized the defendant was going to continue to repeat himself, he engaged the defendant in further conversation. The officer knows that someone who appears to be "stalling", or "making excuses" looks guilty.

Generally, the first officer who makes contact with a possible dui suspect radios for the assistance of a special "dui enforcement officer". The initial officer takes that step because he obviously believes the suspect is DUI. The moment the dui officer gets out of his cruiser to make contact with you, it is important to realize that the video camera is on and you are both, "on stage". As he approaches you the dui officer is presuming guilt because of his conversation with the officer who made the initial stop. The goal of the dui officer is to collect as much incriminating evidence (a poor performance on video) as possible. Sometimes what may sound like "friendly talk", is a method used by officers to document "admissions of guilt" on the video.

DEFENSE: Ultimately, we were able to point out to the state attorney that our client's performance on the video was the result of his panic disorder, not because he was driving under the influence. This was extremely important to the client because it was his second DUI within the past five years. If he had pled straight up to the DUI, he would have lost his license for five years, and done a minimum of 10 days in the Hillsborough County Jail.

RESULT: The Defendant's DUI was dropped, and he received no license suspension.